Advertisement

Government drops wider plans to scrap jury trials

Plans to allow more criminal trials to be heard by a judge without a jury have been dropped as the Government moves to fast-track wider reforms aimed at tackling the record Crown Court backlog.

Justice Secretary Alex Norris said the decision would allow ministers to focus on measures designed to get cases through the courts more quickly and reduce delays for victims.

The Government had previously proposed creating a new Crown Court division where some cases likely to receive sentences of up to three years could be heard by a judge alone. That proposal will now be removed from the Courts and Tribunals Bill.

However, the Government will retain plans to allow judges to hear some particularly technical and lengthy fraud and financial cases without a jury. The change is intended to reduce the time taken by complex trials and avoid jurors having to serve on cases lasting months.

Jury trials will therefore remain for more serious criminal cases, while courts will gain greater control over where some less serious cases are heard.

The Bill will remove defendants’ ability to elect to have triable-either-way offences heard in the Crown Court. Magistrates will also be given greater sentencing powers, allowing more cases to be dealt with without being sent to the Crown Court.

The Government said millions will also be invested in technology and other measures to improve the efficiency of the courts, including greater use of virtual hearings and technology to support case listing.

The changes come as the Crown Court backlog has reached a record level. Ministry of Justice figures show there were 80,829 outstanding cases at the end of June, with almost a third having waited at least a year.

Mr Norris said he had ‘heard the strength of feeling’ over proposals to increase judge-alone trials and had decided to ‘change course’.

He said: ‘This allows us to start that work far earlier, ensuring that under this Government we do not have victims waiting endlessly for justice.’

In response, Bar Council Chair Kirsty Brimelow KC said: ‘This is a significant and welcome move away from reducing the only part of the criminal justice system that actually works, namely jury trials.

‘We welcome the government’s swift action in retaining juries and particularly thank the new Lord Chancellor for listening to the Bar and wider legal profession.

‘Whilst attention is being given to lifting the criminal justice system from its crisis, we underline that it is a dangerous experiment to increase sentencing powers of magistrates and remove the right to elect from defendants at a time when prisons are at capacity and the backlog of cases is accelerating in the magistrates’ courts.

‘The magistrates’ courts are not coping with their caseload whilst the Crown Court backlog is stabilising. Putting more pressure on the magistrates’ courts rather than focusing on reforms that actually are working in reducing delays in the Crown Court is not of benefit to the criminal justice system. We have long called for the focus to be on fixing the swathe of inefficiencies plaguing the system – we know that many can be resolved, and that will make a difference now. In relation to fraud cases, the power to apply for a judge only trial already is in law.

‘We know that women, Black people, mixed race people and older people elect jury trials more often than other groups and this proposal risks deepening existing disparities and exacerbating distrust in the justice system from minoritised communities.

‘We await further details of these plans ahead of the Bill returning to Parliament.’

Paul Day
Paul is the editor of Public Sector News.
Help us break the news – share your information, opinion or analysis
Back to top